OPERATING REVIEW
People, Culture & Leadership
October 2026

The Cruelty of Uncertainty

Leaders cannot always provide certainty, but they can provide clarity. Prolonged silence during consequential decisions carries a real human and organizational cost.

Solitary figure at the end of a quiet hospital corridor.
Healthcare strategy extends beyond the hospital campus.

There is a particular kind of anxiety that comes from waiting for a decision someone else has the authority to make.

Perhaps an employee knows a department is being reorganized but has no idea whether their position will survive. A leader has been told that a restructuring is under consideration but cannot get a straight answer about what it means for their team. Or an organization has spent months discussing a significant change while the people most affected are left to interpret rumors, hallway conversations, and carefully worded assurances.

For those making the decisions, the uncertainty may be one of several issues competing for attention. For those living with the consequences, it may be the only issue that matters.

Uncertainty has a human cost.

It follows people home. It enters conversations with families. It influences financial decisions, career planning, and the willingness to make commitments about the future.

And when uncertainty continues without meaningful communication, people begin filling the silence themselves. They speculate. They look for signals. They interpret what leaders say, what they don't say, and what they appear reluctant to say.

The absence of an answer becomes its own message.

When Silence Becomes a Leadership Decision

There are legitimate reasons leaders cannot immediately provide answers. A decision may not have been made. Financial and strategic alternatives may still be under evaluation. Confidentiality, regulatory requirements, or personnel considerations may limit what can responsibly be disclosed.

These are realities of executive leadership, particularly in complex healthcare organizations.

But there is an important distinction between being unable to provide certainty and being unwilling to provide clarity.

Too often, leaders confuse the two. They delay difficult conversations hoping circumstances will resolve themselves. They offer general reassurances because specifics invite uncomfortable questions. Or they say nothing because they believe incomplete information will create more anxiety than silence.

Sometimes those instincts come from a genuine desire to protect people.

But protection and avoidance are not the same thing.

Brené Brown captures the principle succinctly in Dare to Lead: “Clear is kind. Unclear is unkind.”

In organizational leadership, that principle extends beyond difficult conversations. It reaches into decisions that shape people's professional lives and the effectiveness of the organizations they serve.

Clarity Without Certainty

Employees do not necessarily expect leaders to know everything. They do, however, deserve an honest understanding of what leadership knows, what remains unresolved, and what happens next.

A CEO may not be able to promise that a service line will remain open. A hospital president may not know whether a proposed organizational structure will be approved. A senior executive may be unable to disclose the details of an ongoing negotiation.

But leaders can often explain the process, acknowledge the implications, identify remaining questions, and establish when another update will be provided. And when that update arrives, they can follow through, even if a decision has not been reached.

That communication does more than demonstrate respect. It protects the organization's ability to function.

When employees trust that leadership will communicate candidly, they have less reason to rely on rumors or interpret every organizational development as a warning sign. Managers can spend more time leading their teams and less time

responding to speculation. Valuable employees are less likely to conclude that leaving is their only way to regain control over their futures.

Clarity may not resolve the underlying issue, but it can preserve the trust, attention, and organizational stability needed to navigate it.

The Responsibility That Comes With Authority

One of the privileges of executive leadership is having access to information and influence over decisions that others do not. That privilege carries a corresponding responsibility.

Leaders can become accustomed to uncertainty because they participate in discussions, understand the alternatives, and know why decisions are taking time. Employees often have none of those advantages.

What feels to an executive like a reasonable period of deliberation can feel to an employee like an indefinite suspension of their future.

Effective leaders recognize that imbalance and understand that communication is not simply an obligation to employees. It is an investment in the organization's ability to navigate difficult decisions.

Clarity builds credibility, even when the news is unwelcome. It gives managers the confidence to lead, employees a reason to remain engaged, and organizations a better chance of retaining the people and trust they will need on the other side of change.

The goal is not to eliminate uncertainty. It is to lead through it in a way that strengthens rather than diminishes the organization and the people who make it work.

OPERATING REVIEW

More thinking from the operating side of healthcare.

Strategy, operations, quality, physicians, people, and performance—examined as parts of one interconnected system.

Return to Operating Review →