Health systems have spent decades employing physicians, often with the assumption that employment creates alignment.
It doesn't.
Employment changes the contractual and economic relationship. Alignment is an operating relationship. And how you build that relationship depends considerably on the physician's role in the healthcare system.
A primary care physician, a specialist, and a hospital-based physician group interact with the hospital differently. Expecting the same engagement strategy to work for all three misses the point.
I learned that physician alignment works best when it is built around those differences.
With our employed primary care group in Bakersfield, one of the most important decisions was putting a highly respected physician in the medical director and group leadership role. I attended the group's monthly meetings and routinely shared a modified version of what I would present to our Board—what was happening across the hospital, where the ambulatory network was going, how we were performing, and what we were trying to build.
That wasn't simply communication. It gave physicians visibility into the business and operating decisions affecting the system they were part of.
With hospital-based physician groups, the conversation was different. We spent more time looking together at clinical and operating data: recognizing strong performance, identifying opportunities for improvement, and discussing what physicians needed from the hospital and what the hospital needed from them. Having the CEO, CMO, and CNO involved made it possible to talk directly about accountability on both sides.
Specialists presented another set of opportunities. Those conversations were often about growth: where we could build programs, improve hospital efficiency, expand access, and strengthen relationships with referring physicians. The objective wasn't simply to get specialists to bring more volume to the hospital. It was to engage them in building stronger clinical programs.
Across all of those relationships, one practice remained consistent: share the strategy and the results.
Physicians routinely heard where the organization was going, how we were performing, what wasn't working, and what we were doing about it. We recognized success, but we also invited physicians into the operational realities of the hospital.
That distinction matters.
Physician engagement can easily become a collection of dinners, recognition programs, surveys, and medical staff meetings. Those things have value, but they aren't the same as partnership.
You build alignment when physicians aren't simply informed about the organization, but become participants in improving it.
In Bakersfield, administrative physician engagement increased from the 19th percentile in 2014 to the 65th percentile in 2016, while a separate measure of employed-physician engagement ultimately reached the 90th percentile. During the same period, we expanded primary care, grew major clinical service lines, improved quality, and increased market share.
I don't believe those results came from a single physician-engagement initiative. They came from creating different relationships with different physician groups while consistently treating physicians as partners in the performance and direction of the organization.
Employment can put physicians inside the organization.
Alignment brings them inside the work.
