Healthcare organizations tend to be very good at defining the executive they want to hire.
The candidate should have experience in an organization of similar size and complexity. They should understand the market. They should have managed a comparable operating model, led a similar team and ideally faced many of the same challenges.
All of those requirements are reasonable.
But taken together, they can create an unintended result: we hire for the organization we already have rather than the organization we're trying to become.
Over the course of my career, I've had the opportunity both to build executive teams and, more recently, to help healthcare organizations identify senior leaders. From both sides of the table, I've become increasingly interested in one question:
What are we actually hiring this person to accomplish?
Start with the strategy, not the résumé
If an organization expects the next three to five years to look substantially different from the last three to five, the leadership profile should likely look different as well.
A hospital preparing for aggressive growth may need a different executive than one focused primarily on operational stabilization. A standalone organization entering a larger system may need different capabilities than one committed to remaining independent. An organization pursuing clinical integration, new delivery models or significant digital transformation may need leadership experience that isn't obvious from a conventional comparison of titles and organizational size.
The question shouldn't simply be whether someone has successfully led an organization like ours. It should be whether that person's experience, judgment and capabilities suggest they can lead ours where it needs to go.
Similarity is not the same as readiness
There is an understandable desire to reduce risk in executive selection.
Someone who has already held the same title in a similarly sized organization feels safer. Each additional point of similarity provides another piece of evidence that the candidate can do the job.
Relevant experience matters. But similarity is not the same thing as readiness.
Sometimes the executive who most closely matches the organization as it exists today is exactly the right person. Other times, the organization's strategy requires someone who has operated in a different environment, solved a problem the organization hasn't faced yet or built something the organization doesn't yet have.
That isn't an argument for overlooking experience. It's an argument for defining which experience actually matters.
Hire against the work ahead
Before building an executive profile, I think organizations should be able to articulate the handful of things that leader will actually be expected to accomplish.
Grow the enterprise? Improve operating performance? Build physician alignment? Strengthen quality? Integrate an acquisition? Develop a regional delivery system? Transform the culture? Build a stronger leadership team?
The answers should materially change who we look for.
Culture belongs in that assessment as well. The right executive needs to understand and connect with the culture they are entering, even when part of the assignment is to change it. Transformation doesn't require rejecting everything that came before. It requires the judgment to understand what should be preserved, what needs to evolve and how to bring people with you.
Those priorities should also influence how candidates are evaluated. Instead of asking primarily, Has this person worked somewhere like us?, we can ask, What evidence suggests this person can accomplish what comes next?
Healthcare leadership is changing too quickly for executive selection to become an exercise in reproducing the past. The organization we have still has to perform today. The best leaders have to be capable of operating in the present while building toward something different.
But if we're serious about transformation, growth or improvement, our leadership decisions have to reflect that ambition.
The goal isn't to hire the executive who best matches the organization we have. It's to identify the executive best equipped to lead the organization we need.
