CASE STUDY

Repositioning a Community Hospital as the Market Changed Around It

PRESIDENT & CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER · ZEPHYRHILLS, FLORIDA · 2009–2013

139-bed acute care hospital serving East Pasco County and the greater Tampa Bay region

AdventHealth Zephyrhills hospital main entrance in Zephyrhills, Florida.

Hospital growth is often framed as a question of capturing more share within an existing market. At AdventHealth Zephyrhills, the more fundamental challenge was deciding what the hospital needed to become as the market itself changed.

Zephyrhills had deep roots in East Pasco County and important clinical capabilities, particularly in cardiovascular care. But during my tenure, AdventHealth was rapidly expanding across Tampa Bay. The system expanded through the acquisition of what is now AdventHealth Tampa and other hospital campuses, adding significant tertiary capabilities to the network, while also developing the new AdventHealth Wesley Chapel.

For AdventHealth, that expansion created a much stronger regional system. For Zephyrhills, it fundamentally changed the competitive geography.

Where could Zephyrhills compete most effectively, and what would make patients and physicians choose the hospital even when other options were available?
THE CHALLENGE

A substantial portion of the hospital's western service area, including some of its more commercially attractive communities, was increasingly served by newer or newly affiliated AdventHealth facilities. In some service lines, Zephyrhills was now competing for patients and physicians not only with outside health systems, but with hospitals inside its own system.

AdventHealth Wesley Chapel presented a particularly visible contrast. It was a new hospital serving a growing market while Zephyrhills operated from a considerably older campus.

Simply defending the hospital's historical service area was not going to be enough.

That meant looking beyond the hospital's traditional geography. We increasingly focused on secondary service areas extending north toward Dade City and east and south toward Lakeland, while developing clinical capabilities capable of drawing patients beyond Zephyrhills' immediate community.

Map of the Tampa Bay and East Pasco County market showing AdventHealth Tampa, Carrollwood, Wesley Chapel and Zephyrhills with overlapping service areas.
A Changing Competitive Geography
AdventHealth's expansion across Tampa Bay brought new and newly affiliated hospitals into Zephyrhills' traditional market. The map illustrates how that expansion changed the competitive geography surrounding the hospital.
THE STRATEGIC SHIFT

AdventHealth's strategic planning framework used two connected ideas to frame Quality Initiatives and Business Development: Improve the Product and Grow the Market.

The premise was straightforward.

You cannot sustainably grow a hospital without a strong clinical and operating product. But it also becomes difficult to sustain a great product if the organization is not growing.

At Zephyrhills, those ideas became mutually reinforcing. Better clinical quality, patient experience, physician relationships and operating performance would make the hospital more competitive. Growth in physicians, clinical programs and regional referrals would create the volume, relevance and financial capacity needed to continue improving the product.

Cardiovascular care was already an important strength, so we continued developing the Heart Institute while investing in neuroscience, stroke, orthopedics, spine and surgical services. One of the most significant initiatives was development of a comprehensive Neuroscience Institute in partnership with the University of South Florida, expanding local access to stroke services, brain and spine surgery and neurointerventional care.

The results began showing up in the hospital's competitive position. Neurology market share increased from 39.9% to 55.5%. Cardiovascular market share increased from 62.3% to 69.1%. General Surgery market share increased from 35.1% to 54.4%.

EXECUTION

Clinical growth required a stronger physician platform. We recruited surgical specialists, expanded primary care regionally and strengthened physician relations and referral development. The work included practice development, compensation alignment, coding and revenue cycle improvement, marketing and deliberate regional expansion.

By 2011, the employed group had reduced its practice loss by approximately $1 million and contributed $34.5 million in hospital net revenue. Across the broader tenure, clinic visits in existing employed practices grew an average of 14.3% annually, while employed physician subsidy declined 30%. Overall physician engagement moved from the 19th to the 51st percentile.

As clinical capabilities and volume expanded, we made an equally significant investment in how the hospital operated. We adopted Lean and the Toyota Production System as an operating philosophy, supported by work with Virginia Mason and Japanese Lean practitioners. The objective was not to create a collection of isolated improvement projects. It was to build an operating system.

Inside the hospital, that meant Rapid Process Improvement Workshops, visual management, executive rounding, standard work, daily performance review and redesign of patient flow. The strategic plan ultimately described this approach as the hospital's System of Care, connecting quality, cost, patient experience, physician alignment and clinical growth.

Hours per adjusted admission declined 17.2%, from 116 to 96. Salaries and wages per adjusted admission declined 7.8%. Total expense per adjusted admission declined 8.1%.

Growth and financial discipline were not competing objectives. The organization had to accomplish both.

Improving the product also meant that better operating performance had to translate into better clinical care. The hospital's Core Measure quality composite increased from 86.1% to 99.1%. Overall Hospital Rating moved from the 6th to the 48th percentile, Nurse Communication from the 4th to the 71st percentile, Pain Management from the 4th to the 86th percentile, and Emergency Department Overall Rating from the 6th to the 55th percentile.

REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT

The broader market context was central to the strategy. AdventHealth was building a stronger Tampa Bay network at the same time Zephyrhills was determining its role within that network. New and newly affiliated hospitals to the west changed referral patterns, physician relationships and the economics of the hospital's traditional service area.

Our response was to broaden Zephyrhills' geographic perspective while developing clinical programs capable of attracting patients regionally. The hospital increasingly looked north toward Dade City and east and south toward Lakeland, alongside continued development of relationships across East Pasco County.

The objective was not to recreate the market that had existed before the system expanded. It was to establish a stronger position in the market that was emerging.

RESULTS

Growth, higher performance and a stronger market position.

+23.5%
Acute admissions
43.0% → 51.9%
Inpatient market share
86.1% → 99.1%
Core Measure quality composite
CLINICAL POSITION
39.9% → 55.5%
Neurology market share
35.1% → 54.4%
General Surgery market share
62.3% → 69.1%
Cardiovascular market share
OPERATING PERFORMANCE
116 → 96
Hours per adjusted admission
−8.1%
Expense per adjusted admission
−7.8%
Salaries and wages per adjusted admission
PHYSICIANS
+14.3%
Average annual clinic visit growth in existing employed practices
−30%
Employed physician subsidy
19th → 51st
Overall physician engagement percentile
QUALITY & EXPERIENCE
4th → 71st
Nurse Communication percentile
4th → 86th
Pain Management percentile
6th → 55th
Emergency Department Overall Rating percentile
LEADERSHIP LESSON

It would have been easy to view the changes occurring around Zephyrhills defensively. The hospital's traditional market was changing. New facilities were entering important portions of its service area. Advanced capabilities were becoming available elsewhere within AdventHealth. The physical campus itself could not compete with a brand new hospital on appearance alone.

The more useful question was not how to preserve the market as it had existed. It was what Zephyrhills could become in the market that was emerging.

That required expanding the hospital's geographic perspective, developing clinical capabilities worth traveling for, building a stronger physician platform and creating an operating system capable of supporting growth without sacrificing quality or financial discipline.

The lesson from Zephyrhills was not simply that a hospital can grow in a changing market. It was that improving the product and growing the market are ultimately the same work.